Smriti Mandhana Backs Harmanpreet Kaur’s Outburst Over ‘Pathetic’ Umpiring in India-Bangladesh Cricket ODI


In a dramatic turn of events during the third one-day international (ODI) between India and Bangladesh yesterday, Indian skipper Harmanpreet Kaur’s strong criticism of the umpiring has sparked a heated debate in the cricketing world. However, her fellow teammate, Smriti Mandhana, came forward in unwavering support of her captain’s candid remarks. The incident has shed light on the importance of fair and accurate umpiring decisions in the game and raises questions about the overall state of umpiring in cricket.

The Controversial Umpiring Decision

During the crucial ODI encounter between India and Bangladesh, an umpiring decision became the focal point of the match. It involved a debatable call that left the Indian team and their captain fuming. In the post-match press conference, Harmanpreet Kaur, in an emotionally charged statement, termed the umpiring during the match as “pathetic” and questioned the consistency and fairness of some of the decisions made.

Support from Smriti Mandhana

Following Harmanpreet Kaur’s vocal expression of her displeasure, her teammate Smriti Mandhana came out in full support of the captain. Mandhana emphasized that it is essential to address concerns regarding the standard of umpiring in the game, as it can significantly impact the outcome of matches and tarnish the sport’s integrity.

In a statement, Mandhana said, “As players, we strive to give our best on the field, and it becomes disheartening when decisions that can alter the course of the game are not made with utmost accuracy. Harman expressed her emotions after a highly competitive game, and I believe it was a genuine reflection of her passion for the sport. We all stand by her.”

The Importance of Fair Umpiring

Cricket has always been regarded as a gentleman’s game, where the spirit of sportsmanship and fair play holds utmost significance. Umpires play a vital role in maintaining this spirit by making impartial and correct decisions on the field. Their judgments can turn the tide of a match and impact players’ careers, making the need for consistent and accurate umpiring absolutely critical.

However, in recent years, the issue of controversial umpiring decisions has become more prevalent. With the advent of technology, the introduction of Decision Review System (DRS) has somewhat helped in reducing errors, but it is not foolproof and not available in every cricket match. As a result, human umpires still have a significant role to play, and their competence and consistency come under scrutiny regularly.

Improving Umpiring Standards

Harmanpreet Kaur’s outspoken criticism highlights the urgency for cricketing authorities to address umpiring standards seriously. The boards must invest in proper training and development programs for umpires to ensure they are up-to-date with the latest rules and regulations. Regular evaluations and feedback sessions can also help identify areas of improvement for individual umpires.

Furthermore, leveraging technology to a greater extent can enhance umpiring accuracy. Expanding the use of DRS and considering the implementation of other technological aids, such as ball-tracking and UltraEdge, can significantly reduce errors and improve the overall umpiring process.


The recent incident involving Harmanpreet Kaur’s outburst over the umpiring decisions during the India-Bangladesh ODI has brought the issue of umpiring standards into the limelight. Smriti Mandhana’s unwavering support for her captain further emphasizes the significance of fair and accurate umpiring decisions in cricket. It is crucial for cricketing authorities to take this matter seriously and work towards improving umpiring standards through proper training, technology integration, and regular evaluations. Only by doing so can we maintain the essence of cricket as a gentleman’s game and uphold its integrity in the eyes of millions of fans worldwide.

Leave a Comment